Cauliflower and Fennel Gratin (say “bechamel” 10 time fast)

cauliflower-fennel-gratin2

My predilection for comfort dishes means that gratins, bechamel and cheese are recurring themes, but before I begin, forgive me a small rant: there is a fine line between a dish that is richly delicious, and one that is so packed with cream and butter that you can barely eat a second bite.  Too many restaurants err on the wrong side of that line.

I remember reading the author of Cooking School Confidential write about learning the optimal way to prep potatoes for mashing in order to get as much butter into them as possible.  My first reaction was “interesting” and my second was “maybe this is why I never like the mashed potatoes in restaurants.”

It reminds me of watching Anne Burrell explain, as she grabbed a huge handful of salt, how restaurant food is tasty because it is “better seasoned.”  And I thought, “is that a euphamism for salty?”  It is true that many tentative home cooks under-salt in the cooking process, but at least guests have a chance to rectify that.  I find American Italian restaurants to be the worst offenders of over-salting.

This isn’t just about health, although that is relevant to this topic, but just the observation that more is not always better.  I understand a restaurant’s desire to exude luxury, but you shouldn’t need a red wine strong enough to punch you in the jaw to make it through more than a few bites of a dish.

Now isn’t that a marvelously hypocritical way to introduce a dish with bechamel (one with more butter than flour even!) and cheese?!  This dish is not something I would eat every night, but it was utterly delicious and while it went right smack up to the aforementioned line, it stayed just on the right side.

I’d quip that I ate my hypocrisy most happily, but perhaps the serious  analysis is that the term “too rich” is subjectively like what the judge said about pornography: “I can’t define it, but I know it when I see it.”

Cauliflower and Fennel Gratin

Bechamel
4 tbsp unsalted butter
3 tbsp flour
2 cups milk
1/4 tsp salt

Gratin
a head of cauliflower
1 large fennel bulb, including fronds
2/3 cup grated gruyere or comte cheese
2 or 3 thick slices of country bread
1/4 tsp ground nutmeg
salt and pepper
2 tbsp butter

Making the Bechamel
Heat the milk up to a simmer and then turn off the heat.  Melt the butter on low heat in a medium sauce pan, then add the flour and cook for 2 minutes, constantly stirring the flour into the butter. Add a small amount of milk (about 2 tbsp worth) and stir in. Repeat two or three times.  At this point stir in the rest of the milk in 1/2 cup amounts, stirring constantly.  You can turn up the heat a smidgen, and keep on stirring regularly until the sauce thickens to the consistency of heavy cream.  Turn off the heat.

Prepping the Gratin

Make the breadcrumbs by ripping the bread into smaller pieces and pulsing in a food processor.  Spread out on a baking tray. Butter a baking dish (separate from the tray) for the gratin with the 2 tbsp, and then chop up and scatter the remaining butter over the bread crumbs in the baking tray.

Turn on the broiler and cook the breadcrumbs on the lowest rack (or set oven to a lower heat) until they are just turning golden. Remove from the oven and stir the breadcrumbs around. Reserve.

Cut off the tops of the fennel bulb, slice off a thin piece of the bottom, and discard the outer layer if really tough.  Save and finely chop the fine fennel fronds from the tops.  Cut the bulb in half and then slice into 1/2 inch thick pieces.  Cut or break the cauliflower into bite-size florets.

Scatter the fennel and cauliflower around the baking dish — you want enough vegetables to fill the dish.  Drizzle a little olive oil on top, sprinkle some coarse salt around, and mix the vegetables with two spoons.  Place under the broiler near the top of the oven for a short period to lightly brown the tops of the vegetables (keep an eye on this and do not let it burn).

Remove from the oven and turn the heat down to 350F.  Grind some fresh pepper on top and mix the vegetables again.  Cover the fennel and cauliflower with the bechamel, then sprinkle the cheese on top, and then the breadcrumbs.  Sprinkle the nutmeg and the chopped fennel fronds on top (no more than a tbsp of the fennel fronds).  Bake for 40 to 50 minutes, until golden on top.

cauliflower-fennel-gratin

  • Sigari

    What wine recommendations do you have for this dish, please?

  • I could see this as a stand-alone dish for dinner, with a salad alongside. Or for a side dish to a special meal. Looks scrumptious.

  • Giff,
    May I file this in my recipe box under Giff’s Gratins?
    I love cauliflower and fennel and want to say that 10 times!

  • Gratin is good – always. Interesting comments on salt. I certainly know when something is NOT seasoned – but the proper balance of seasonings can be an art form itself. Great to see you at the Foodbuzz event last night!

  • Giff

    Sigari – nothing too light or too fruity. A cabernet sauvignon, strong red zin, or full bodied rhone wine would be my preference.

    ciaochowlinda – I agree. A side salad, or if you are non vegetarian, a nicely marinated and grilled london boil cut, thinly sliced (maybe with some mustard).

    Stacey – I like the ring of Giff’s Gratins 🙂 Great seeing you at the foodbuzz event

    TW – agree with you re: seasoning. It really can be an art form, even if some these days think cooking should be boiled down to empirically measured and exactly repeatable recipes. That’s definitely not me, or my favorite cookbook authors and bloggers 🙂

  • kat

    Keeping that one bookmarked for when we get our fennel later this summer. The salt thing is a real issue right now with the news of how much extra salt is in food at restaurants. I’m a light salter myself but oh I cannot resist the butter!

  • I have got to try this one! I love fennel! Great dish!

  • Oh yum! I agree with one of the commenters that said this dish could stand alone with a large glass of red zinfandel.

  • I’m with you on many points you make here … gratins are delicious but they can quickly get TOO rich; and I salt enough to please my palate and if anyone else might like some additional seasoning, they are more than welcome to add it.

    The cauliflower and fennel sound really great together. This and a salad and I think you’ve got a meal ready to serve.

  • Hi Giff – It was great meeting you at the foodbuzz event the other night. You have such a fantastic site here! I am obsessing over your photos!

  • The way I see it, Béchamel has more milk than flour+butter. Ergo it is good for you.

  • Giff

    LOL @ claire, yes bechamel must definitely good for you 🙂

    Culinary Wannabe, nice to meet you as well. Thank you for kind comments on the photos. I feel they have a long way to improve but nice to know that some folks enjoy em!

  • bee

    i dont’ really like cauliflower (something about the smell. love the leaves, though), but i’m looking forward to trying this – sans the bechamel. we’ve planted some so i hope o get a head or two.

  • Looks delicious. It would be hard for me to say something is “too rich” though. I’m not sure I’ve ever said that about any dish. I’m just nuts about really rich food. I suppose the nice layer of fat around my belly is evidence of that.

    Claire is right!

    I think sometimes chefs use a lot of salt because so many of them are heavy smokers and just don’t have good enough taste buds to know when something is seasoned properly.

  • That cheesy cauliflower looks really good and I have been wanting to use fennel more.

  • That sounds truly and wonderfully comforting!!

  • Sigari

    What wine recommendations do you have for this dish, please?